Pros: the lowest upfront price, light weight, and a clean, traditional look on simple roofs. Cons: lower wind ratings, a shorter lifespan and a flat appearance. Color choices are limited, and many manufacturers have scaled back their 3 tab lines, which can make matching repairs harder later.
Pros: better wind and impact resistance, a longer lifespan, stronger warranties and much richer curb appeal. The thicker profile also hides minor deck imperfections. Cons: a higher upfront cost and more weight, though most homes handle it easily.
On a typical Northern Virginia home, architectural shingles add about 10 to 20 percent to the cost of the roof. Spread over a lifespan that can run 10 years longer, the cost per year is often lower. See our breakdown of roof replacement cost in Northern Virginia.
Buyers and home inspectors notice the roof. A dimensional shingle roof reads as newer and higher-end, and it can be a selling point in competitive neighborhoods.